Tim Thomas doesn't give B's big edge
Short series limits impact of even the best netminders
Tim Thomas is the heavy Vezina favorite and a potential nominee for the Hart Trophy as league MVP after setting the single-season record for save percentage with a mark of .938. Given that, you might think that no matter how the rest of the Boston Bruins matched up against their first-round opponent, Boston could at least count on superior goaltending.
Yet through three games, things have not gone as expected. Thomas gave up a crucial early goal in each of the first two games against the Montreal Canadiens, struggling with his rebound control, especially in Game 2, when bad caroms turned into Montreal goals. Even in the Bruins' lone win in Game 3, in which Thomas was able to hold his team in against some late Habs pressure, both Montreal goals were sharp-angle shots that slipped between Thomas' pads.
At the other end of the ice, the Habs' Carey Price -- no slouch in the regular season -- has stood tall with a .956 save percentage. A bad bounce while handling the puck led to the Bruins' winning goal in Game 3, yet Price has made a number of big saves to keep the underdog Canadiens in the series. And, through two contests, Boston's so-called advantage in goal has completely failed to materialize. But that shouldn't be too surprising.
Last year's playoffs saw all the Vezina nominees knocked out in the first round, eliminated at the hands of a journeyman (Brian Boucher) and two rookies (Jimmy Howard and Tuukka Rask). All the league's elite goalies were well into their golf seasons by the time Antti Niemi's Blackhawks beat out Michael Leighton and the Flyers in the Stanley Cup finals. Perhaps it's time to accept what the evidence overwhelmingly suggests: Having the better goalie is not an unbeatable advantage in a playoff series.
To see why the value of goaltending in the playoffs is greatly overstated and why Tim Thomas doesn't provide much of an advantage for the Bruins, you must be an ESPN Insider.
MORE NHL HEADLINES
- Couture rescues Sharks in OT, cuts Kings' lead
- NHL fines Sharks $100K for GM's comments
- Red Wings blitz Blackhawks to even series
- Sens' Spezza to return Sunday against Pens
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
NHL Insider Content
STANLEY CUP PLAYOFFS
Prospectus: Rating B's, Canucks' depth
CapGeek: Bs, Canucks provide cap blueprints Conn Smythe Watch: Thomas takes the lead
Greenberg: Projecting Tyler Seguin
Greenberg: Lapierre is Canucks' MVP
Prospectus: Special teams aren't that key
Conn Smythe Watch: Kesler's charge
Joyce: Sharks stars lack 'it'
Greenberg: Best Gs vs. the best shots
Conn Smythe Watch: Thomas rises
Button: Philly's crisis of crease confidence
Greenberg: Can blocks carry Bolts to Cup?
Prospectus: Ranking Caps' playoff failure
Prospectus: Top playoff rooks since 1998
Conn Smythe Watch: Roloson No. 1
Prospectus: Datsyuk remains underrated
Conn Smythe Watch: Neuvirth shines
Greenberg: Best D pairs vs. Alex Ovechkin
Prospectus: Thomas doesn't give B's big edge
Prospectus: Playoff team depth rankings
Cooper: Preds try to ditch Rd. 1 jinx
Prospectus: Team-by-team odds to win the Cup
Prospectus: Ranking the first-round netminders
Prospectus: These Sharks built to last
Prospectus: Puck luck could pluck Ducks
Cooper: Why playoff hockey is so different
Team Scouting Reports
How to beat the Boston Bruins
How to beat the Philadelphia Flyers
How to beat the Pittsburgh Penguins
How to beat the Washington Capitals
How to beat the Anaheim Ducks
How to beat the Detroit Red Wings
How to beat the San Jose Sharks
How to beat the Vancouver Canucks
May 11: Why Wings may soon fall off
April 28: Strome surges in Mock Draft 2.0
April 13: Nashville tries to overcome history
April 11: D. Sedin tops final player rankings
April 7: Coaches feeling the hot seat
April 6: How Caps' draft strategy has worked
March 30: Can Flyers win Cup with Bobrovsky?
March 9: Re-ranking Top 50 draft prospects
Feb. 28: Traded prospect evals
Feb. 28: Rating trades in the West
Feb. 28: Rating trades in the East
Feb. 17: Worst. Trades. Ever.
Feb. 17: NHL Mock Draft 1.0
NHL Rumor Central
Get news and rumblings before anyone
NHL Experts Blog
Daily ice shavings of insight
NHL Draft Blog
A look towards June 2011