Niemi vs. Leighton -- and what it means
The Cup-contending goaltenders underscore a lesson on playoff netminding
- Icon SMINiemi and Leighton have been lights-out when the lights go up.
As Christmas 2009 approached, Michael Leighton had been pushed out of his job as backup goaltender for the last-place Carolina Hurricanes and was picked up off waivers by the injury-riddled Philadelphia Flyers practically out of desperation. By season's end, the 6-foot-3, 29-year-old netminder had recorded an uninspiring .905 save percentage, accumulating only 1.4 GVT (Puck Prospectus' value metric). That mark is just barely above the replacement level of 0, but Brian Boucher's postseason knee injury left the Flyers with only Leighton in their quest for the Stanley Cup.
Six wins and 3½ shutouts later, the Flyers stand in the finals ready to face down the Chicago Blackhawks. As wonderful as Leighton has been lately, he has generally uninspiring career averages (2.94 GAA, .902 save percentage). The achievement raises an interesting question about the value of goaltending in the playoffs, particularly because the Blackhawks entered the playoffs with below-average goaltending as well.
How did these types of teams get here? Does their offense compensate for this weakness between the pipes? Do the goalies just get hot? Does their defense step it up? Or is it all just a fluke?
In short, are goalies as important in the playoffs as we've been led to believe?
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
We see that you are not an ESPN Insider. Upgrade today and gain access to our exclusive coverage.
MORE NHL HEADLINES
- Sutter sends Pens past Ducks in shootout
- Luongo shuts out Sabres in return to Florida
- Franzen's 2 goals highlight Wings' barrage
- Rangers use late rally to outstrip Hurricanes
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
NHL Playoffs On Insider
Insider keeps you informed -- dare we say inside the game -- every step of the playoffs (and we even talk June's draft).
NHL draft 2010
- The most recent mock draft effort (June 3)
- 5/27: Best talent-seeking teams
- 5/25: The latest stock watch
- 5/20: The Russian risk and Kabanov
- 5/15: Taylor Hall profile
- 5/7: Tyler Seguin profile
- Franklin Philadelphia Flyers Kids' Uniform Set
- NHL Home
- Carolina Hurricanes
- Columbus B. Jackets
- New Jersey Devils
- New York Islanders
- New York Rangers
- Philadelphia Flyers
- Pittsburgh Penguins
- Washington Capitals
- Boston Bruins
- Buffalo Sabres
- Detroit Red Wings
- Florida Panthers
- Montreal Canadiens
- Ottawa Senators
- Tampa Bay Lightning
- Toronto Maple Leafs