Commentary
Rating NFL head-coaching hires
A study has shown that "retreads" are more successful than first-timers. So who wins?
Updated: February 14, 2012, 8:31 AM ET
By
Seth Wickersham | ESPN The Magazine
A couple of years ago, I wrote about quantitative methods that NFL teams and independent researchers had devised in the desperate search to find the next great coach. (I swear, the story was more exciting than that.) These folks, ranging from team execs to college professors, analyzed more than 100 hires, breaking down dozens of traits from experience to race to coaching trees. As I wrote, the vast majority of successful coaches possessed at least one of the following four characteristics:
To see which teams aced their hires based on the NYU parameters, become an ESPN Insider today.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Seth Wickersham joined ESPN The Magazine after graduating from the University of Missouri. Although he primarily covers the NFL, his assignments also have taken him to the Athens Olympics, the World Series, the NCAA tournament and the NHL and NBA playoffs. Email him and follow him on Twitter at @sethwickersham.
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- DE Freeney, Chargers agree to contract
- Mario Williams' ex alleges suicide-talk texts
- Source: Gronkowski may need back surgery
- Jets' Goodson arrested for drugs, weapons
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
The NFL on ESPN.com

NFL DRAFT ON ESPN
- Round 1: 3 hours
- Day 2: 7 p.m. ET, ESPN & WatchESPN
- Day 3: 12 p.m. ET, ESPN & WatchESPN
NFL DRAFT PROFILES
- Merrill: How dad molded Andrew Luck
- The Mag: Burfict fighting perception
- Mag: Griffin III is no ordinary QB
- Chadiha: Kuechly looks like a sure thing
- Fox: DT Poe races up the board
- Chadiha: Jenkins trying to rebuild image
HOT BUTTON: KIPER-MCSHAY DEBATES
- Who's the second-best RB in the draft?
- Which player is getting too much hype?
- Which team has toughest call in top 10?
- Which probable 2nd-rounder belongs in 1st?
- Which Day 2 QB will have best career?
NFL DRAFT TEAM NEEDS
- Horton: NFC East needs | W | N | S

- Horton: AFC East needs | W | N | S

MORE NFL COVERAGE
- Fox: Skins create another QB controversy
- Clayton: Players control Pro Bowl's fate
- Clayton: Draft drama starts at No. 3
- Fox: The draft is just the beginning
- Brandt: A peek inside a draft war room
- Joyner: Five overrated draft prospects

- TMQ: Annual mock draft mockery
- Scouts Inc.: The secondary QB market

- NFL Blog Network: Mock draft 2.0
- Clayton mailbag: Jags, Fins in tough spots
- Fox: Vikings could shake up draft, more
- Williamson: Plenty of draft intrigue here

- Fox: Reaching in draft is a mistake
- Walker: Dolphins are no easy fix
- Polian: Ranking best-drafting teams

- Next Level: Risk of drafting a top-10 QB
- Mag: Stanford four could make history
MORE NFL DRAFT
- Mocks: Kiper 5.0
| McShay 6.0
- Ranks:
McShay top 32 | Kiper Big Board - Cheat Sheets:
QB | RB | WR | TE | OL - More Cheat Sheets:
DL | LB | DB - Kiper's 'Grade A' drafts:
AFC | NFC - McShay: Stacking the 2012 draft board

-
McShay: Seven tiers of draft talent

- Gallery: Top offensive prospects
- Gallery: Top 10 defenders
- Complete draft order | Draft home
- Sprow: Count on a Chiefs rebound in 2013
- Bowen: Jets D can thrive without Revis
- Tuley: 10 best early value NFL bets
- Red Flags: NFC East | North | South
- Kiper: 2014 Big Board | Top TEs | OLBs | ILBs


