Commentary

Ranking the DTs: Ngata is No. 1

The Baltimore Ravens Pro Bowler leads all defensive tackles

Originally Published: August 25, 2011
By Matt Williamson | Scouts Inc.

After watching games and breaking down film, Scouts Inc. has evaluated and graded more than 2,500 NFL players heading into the 2011 season. Here's how the defensive tackles stacked up.

There are a lot of great defensive tackles in the league right now, but nobody is quite like Haloti Ngata at this point. He's the total package, with elite size, quickness and explosiveness. He's a run-stopper, a pass-rusher, a disruptor in every sense. He's setting the standard. What is that standard?

Well, for this exercise, "defensive tackle" represents a range. We go from the massive two-gapping nose tackle types to the long, leaner, athletic 3-technique tackles who explode off the ball, can run and are just rare athletes. And, of course, you see everything in between. So in a way here, we are comparing apples to oranges, but still, the truly elite specimens at defensive tackle are just different from 99.9 percent of the people walking the planet. You know when you watch Ngata.

1
Haloti Ngata
92
AGE: 27
DOB: 1/21/84
HT: 6-4
WT: 330
POS: DT
Tkl 63
Solo 46
Sack 5.5
Int 0
FF 0
TD 0
Player Analysis

Ngata has been a mainstay on the interior of the Ravens' defense since entering the league in 2006. He is one of the largest and most powerful interior defensive linemen in the NFL.

MORE ANALYSIS

He has excellent foot agility and quickness for his size. Ngata can push the pocket with strength to bull rush offensive linemen. He feels pad pressure well and uses his hands effectively to gain leverage and restrict running lanes. He was an impact pass-rusher in 2010. He is a versatile lineman who can align in more than one position in the Ravens' 4-3 scheme.

CLOSE ANALYSIS

2
Justin Smith
90
AGE: 31
DOB: 9/30/79
HT: 6-4
WT: 285
POS: DT
Tkl 70
Solo 57
Sack 8.5
Int 0
FF 1
TD 0
Player Analysis

Smith has been a consistent producer and brings an excellent combination of size, speed, athleticism along with a high level of intensity and effort. He has lost a step over the years, but compensates with excellent technique and the ability to key and diagnose while reacting to blocking schemes.

MORE ANALYSIS

He feels and fights through pressure and is quick to locate the level of the ball and leverage his way to the action. He is a solid performer who may lack premier pass-rushing speed or the bulk to be a dominant run defender, but is an excellent combination of the two.

CLOSE ANALYSIS

3
Vince Wilfork
89
AGE: 29
DOB: 11/4/81
HT: 6-2
WT: 325
POS: DT
Tkl 57
Solo 46
Sack 2.0
Int 0
FF 0
TD 0
Player Analysis

Wilfork is one of the most powerful interior defenders in the league. He is a very good athlete for his size, showing lateral agility between the tackles. He can push the pocket with a bull rush technique from the inside, but his production as pass-rusher is average at best.

MORE ANALYSIS

He feels pad pressure well and reacts quickly as blocking schemes unfold. He has strong hand with a powerful initial punch to hold the point of attack. He is a load inside and rarely gives ground as a run defender.

CLOSE ANALYSIS

4
Kyle Williams
88
AGE: 28
DOB: 6/10/83
HT: 6-1
WT: 303
POS: DT
Tkl 77
Solo 54
Sack 5.5
Int 0
FF 0
TD 0
Player Analysis

Williams has short legs and arms but plays very low to the ground with a good center of gravity. He does a nice job of playing through or over blocks.

MORE ANALYSIS

He uses his hands well to control the blocker at the point of attack. He is more of a short-area playmaker with quickness and power to penetrate gaps. He does not run very well or make a lot of plays outside the tackles. He can collapse the pocket as a pass rusher and has developed a decent counter move off his initial bull rush attack.

CLOSE ANALYSIS

5
Kevin Williams
87
AGE: 31
DOB: 8/16/80
HT: 6-5
WT: 311
POS: DT
Tkl 39
Solo 27
Sack 1.0
Int 0
FF 1
TD 0
Player Analysis

Kevin Williams had another solid season for the Vikings defense but had a noticeable drop off sack production in 2010. Williams has been one of the most consistent durable interior defenders in the league over his eight year career.

MORE ANALYSIS

He has an excellent combination of size, strength and athleticism. He can push the pocket with natural strength and quickness and has a variety of pass-rush moves. He has a great feel for how to restrict running lanes and penetrate gaps. Williams has strong, active hands to control his opponent, which enables him separate effectively in traffic. He can be a relentless defender who often draws double teams, freeing up linebackers at the second level. Kevin Williams brings consistency, experience and attitude to the Minnesota roster.

CLOSE ANALYSIS