Ranking the OGs: Mankins is No. 1
Patriots' Logan Mankins is the top guard in the league
After watching games and breaking down film, Scouts Inc. has evaluated and graded more than 2,500 NFL players heading into the 2011 season. Here's how the guards stacked up.
Let's face it, guards aren't always pretty and are perhaps the easiest position to overlook on the field. But they too need to be both agile and extremely powerful.
Mostly, I want toughness and attitude from this position.
These are the guys that you want to have your back in a bar fight.
In looking at the grades, we honestly could rearrange the top five in almost any way, but Logan Mankins is the best.



Mankins has a good combination of size, athleticism and strength. He is quick to gain leverage with proper hand use and technique. He has strong hands to lock on and stay connected.
Mankins will get overextended at times in the run game but does have the ability to recover with good athleticism. He's not an overpowering player. He's struggled versus power rushers. He has been remarkably durable throughout his career.



Since being drafted by the Saints in the fourth round of the 2006 draft, Evans has been a fixture at the guard position. He has started all 16 games in each of the five seasons he has been in New Orleans and has done a consistent job of getting his game to a new level each and every year.
He has prototypical dimensions for the position with very good initial quickness and agility. He is quick to react and adjust to movement in space and does a good job of getting in front of the play when pulling.
He is a natural knee bender that will keep his pad level down to leverage blocks and can get push or movement on drive blocks. He keeps his feet alive and active to sustain and finish his blocks off.



Nicks is a massive guard with long arms and above-average agility and body control. He took over the starting job early in his rookie season and has played in and started all 16 games both in 2009 and 2010.
He is not a natural knee bender but generally manages to play under his pads and over his feet and does a good job of sustaining his blocks. He flashes the ability to roll his hips to drive opponents out of the hole and keeps his feet alive after initial contact.
He has gotten a lot better about finishing his blocks off, and does a good job of using his hands and steering opponents on by the hole or the pocket.



Sitton is a short, thick lineman with good power and limited athleticism. He is a tough player who locks on and works to finish as a run blocker.
He has decent initial pop with his hands but needs to stay connected with more consistency. He lacks quickness and agility in space to make blocks on the second level. He can anchor well versus powerful bull-rushers but quick interior defenders can give him problems.



Snee plays bigger than his dimensions would indicate due to toughness and natural power at the point of attack. He has strong hands to grab and control defenders quickly.
He shows excellent initial quickness off the snap to gain leverage. He can get into position quickly and does a nice job of keeping his feet balanced to cut off the defender.
He can find the moving target when pulling. He plays with good leverage and pad level throughout the entire play. He shows excellent vision in pass protection.
He reacts well to changing fronts, stunts and twists. Snee is another consistent performer along the Giants' offensive line who should continue to play at a high level in 2011.
To see the rest of the rankings for offensive guards -- and to have access to the rest of the Top 200 -- you must be an ESPN Insider. Sign up today!
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
- NFL Scout for ESPN and Scouts Inc.
- Joined ESPN in 2005
- Was an NFL and college scout for the Cleveland Browns
Connect with Facebook to share your ESPN activities. Learn more »
Learn more- Social Sharing ON ▼
- ON OFF ▼
- Remind me every time I add an event to my Activity
- My Activity ▼
- Recently shared to your timeline:
The NFL on ESPN.com

- Follow the NFL on ESPN on Facebook
- 2011 NFL Preview: Predictions, more
- Fantasy football | Year of the QB
WEEK 1 PICKS
MORE NFL COVERAGE
- Verhei: Are the Falcons backsliding?
- Williamson: Miller key in Denver rebuilding
- Fox: Bradford faces heightened expectations
- Schefter 10 Spot: 5 new playoff teams?
- Dilfer: Preseason prep really does matter

- Wojciechowski: Packers are better in 2011
- Horton: Steelers are explosive
- Seifert: Cobb makes presence felt
- Yasinskas: Defensive issues cost Saints
- Flem File: A day in the life of Vick
- Outsiders: Is Pittsburgh's defense too old?

- Graziano: Giants must lean hard on Manning
- Wojciechowski: 46 predictions for 2011
- Rookie Watch: Newton needs time
- Scouts Inc.: Week 1 game previews

2011 NFL PREVIEW
- Expert picks: Super Bowl, MVP, more
- AFC East: Buffalo | Mia. | N.E. | NY Jets
- AFC North: Balt. | Cinc. | Cleve. | Pitt.
- AFC South: Hou. | Indy | Jax | Tenn.
- AFC West: Den. | K.C. | Oak. | S.D.
- NFC East: Dallas | NYG | Phila. | Wash.
- NFC North: Chi. | Det. | G.B. | Minnesota
- NFC South: Atl. | Car. | N.O. | Tampa
- NFC West: Ariz. | S.F. | St. Louis | Sea.
JOHN CLAYTON QB RANKINGS
NFL DRAFT

- mortreport Chris Mortensen
#FF @GENRaYOdierno @wwpinc @IAVA @WhoRUCarrying @SemperFiFund @TeamRWB @VFWHQ @PatTillmanFnd @AmericanLegion @WarriorWriters #MemorialDay
9 minutes ago
- mortreport Chris Mortensen

- MikeReiss Mike Reiss
Story on @ESPNBoston: WR Brandon Lloyd's outside perspective could be what offense was missing in 2011. http://t.co/44WT69xx
about an hour ago
- MikeReiss Mike Reiss

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
Von Miller will be Top 20 on this list next year at this time
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
T Gonzo at #53? Oh dear NO. HOF? Yes. Best TE of all time? Maybe. But now? Please
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
.@jagzman04 Not sure if I prefer S Smith or Jennings, but I will def take Jennings over R White
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
55 might be a bit high for P Peterson, but I have NO DOUBT that he is very close to being a very special player....shutdown CB-soon
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Refreshing. RT @AdamReisinger: Indy fans chanting "Thank you Pacers."
about 9 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
.@noobontheloose Nah, Jennings is the better all around WR than M Wallace
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
.@AnthonyMosby Of course Jennings plays w the best QB of guys I named....Jennings plays with the best QB in the NFL Bro!
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
Still watching Top 100...Is G Jennings a Top 5 WR? Love this guy-tend to think so, but Calvin, Fitz & prob Andre J are still over him today
about 9 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright
Bears blog: Audio: Wiggins talks Tice, Forte http://t.co/STSS3qLB
about 9 hours ago
- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright

- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Wade's acceleration is striking. Truly compelling athlete.
about 10 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
J Vilma is 58the best player in football? Doesn't belong in the Top 200 anymore...& I am only judging him on the field....absurd
about 10 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
I have made more than my share of Lists/Power Rankings in my day-no one ever approves, but J Long is closer to the Top 10 or 15 than 59th
about 10 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
I know he was injured/down last yr, but no way are there 58 better NFL players than Jake Long
about 10 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright
Wiggins, who had big years for Mike Tice in Minnesota, said TEs can put up solid numbers in Tice's offense in Chicago.
about 10 hours ago
- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright

- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright
Fmr TE Jermaine Wiggins, now a host in Boston, just told us he wishes Wes Welker would've taken Forte route & not signed franchise tender.
about 10 hours ago
- ESPNChiBears Dickerson and Wright

- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Wade...WoW
about 10 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
RT @PFF_NateJahnke: Top 5 Run Blocking TEs in 2011: 1. Martellus Bennett 2. Rob Gronkowski 3. Joel Dreessen 4. Todd Heap 5. Lance Kendricks
about 11 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
Y'all def need to Follow @4nlong
about 11 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- NFL Future Power Rankings: GB is No. 1
- Joyner: Five breakout QB candidates
- Polian: NFL's most pivotal players in 2012
- Kiper: 2013 Big Board | 2012 breakouts
- FBO: NFC East needs | West | South | North

FOLLOW THE NFL ON TWITTER
