The case for Tim Tebow
Why does Tebow need to be a great passer now to be a good NFL quarterback?
This is what you expected, right?
Here you have a young quarterback perpetually impatient with the play, ready to trust his legs as much as a good throwing lane and unafraid of a hit in a way that terrifies his coaches, and he could get pushed into the starting role -- at least partially, you could argue -- because of his name. He's had a few starts, so there's little to project off of. "At first, he wanted to run every time he got back there," says his coach, who insists there is not a single play in the playbook designed for his quarterback to run. "I think he could be a running back in this league," a teammate says. "I've seen [him] run over linebackers and then bounce back to the huddle."
And to go with the running problem, the lefty with the big college stats doesn't have a big arm. But he knows the angles, and how to explain away flaws. "As far as arm strength goes, there are people who have been successful with less. Joe Montana, to name one," the quarterback says. "John Elway was 'confused' before he 'arrived.'"
It all makes Tim Tebow so hard to evaluate. Thing is, these quotes aren't about Tebow -- they're about Steve Young.
Those coaching frustrations, the teammate views, the player himself -- it's all from a Chicago Tribune story that was written eight months before Tebow was born (he's 24 now), about a 25-year-old Young, who was being handed the keys to the Tampa Bay offense in November 1986. It's a reminder that the NFL has always had issues with this type of quarterback -- the kid who can pass, but a lot of his instincts don't fit the traditional NFL model.
Ultimately, Young struggled and was traded away from Tampa in frustration; he was viewed as a bust. He didn't become a starter, then a star, for years. Perhaps Tebow also will be traded at some point, a wasted pick, a project for another coach. But there's also good reason to think that Tebow can be a very good NFL quarterback because, in the same way Tampa once miscalculated on Young, there's reason to think we haven't done a good job of accurately deciphering what a quarterback like Tebow can do.
To read more about why Tim Tebow will be a successful NFL QB, you must be an ESPN Insider.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
The NFL on ESPN.com

- Follow the NFL on ESPN on Facebook
- 2011 NFL Preview: Predictions, more
- Fantasy football | Year of the QB
WEEK 1 PICKS
MORE NFL COVERAGE
- Verhei: Are the Falcons backsliding?
- Williamson: Miller key in Denver rebuilding
- Fox: Bradford faces heightened expectations
- Schefter 10 Spot: 5 new playoff teams?
- Dilfer: Preseason prep really does matter

- Wojciechowski: Packers are better in 2011
- Horton: Steelers are explosive
- Seifert: Cobb makes presence felt
- Yasinskas: Defensive issues cost Saints
- Flem File: A day in the life of Vick
- Outsiders: Is Pittsburgh's defense too old?

- Graziano: Giants must lean hard on Manning
- Wojciechowski: 46 predictions for 2011
- Rookie Watch: Newton needs time
- Scouts Inc.: Week 1 game previews

2011 NFL PREVIEW
- Expert picks: Super Bowl, MVP, more
- AFC East: Buffalo | Mia. | N.E. | NY Jets
- AFC North: Balt. | Cinc. | Cleve. | Pitt.
- AFC South: Hou. | Indy | Jax | Tenn.
- AFC West: Den. | K.C. | Oak. | S.D.
- NFC East: Dallas | NYG | Phila. | Wash.
- NFC North: Chi. | Det. | G.B. | Minnesota
- NFC South: Atl. | Car. | N.O. | Tampa
- NFC West: Ariz. | S.F. | St. Louis | Sea.
JOHN CLAYTON QB RANKINGS
NFL DRAFT

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
Jeremy Lin raises awareness and opens dialogue - ESPN New York http://t.co/FGj9PNt3
about 3 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- wingoz trey wingo
My swing RT @jDerekBoliek: @wingoz what's your handicap?
about 4 hours ago
- wingoz trey wingo

- wingoz trey wingo
Trust me, you dont RT @LukeDavidiuk: @wingoz I want to see a pic of you playing golf.
about 5 hours ago
- wingoz trey wingo

- wingoz trey wingo
RT @MelKiperESPN: Robert Griffin III interview on @DariandMel - http://t.co/xfQcRY2l
about 5 hours ago
- wingoz trey wingo
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Reading Finley responses reminds me of time as NFL team negotiator. Most are asking "What about Flynn?" On to the next.
about 6 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Deal for @JermichaelF88 goes through 2013. By then team will know if @GregJennings has re-upped. Contract expires after this season.
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
.@ericdkennedy @LanceZierlein Agreed, #Dolphins make most sense-most familiar with Flynn
about 7 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
I am told @JermichaelF88 will receive $10.2 million from the Packers over the next 13 months.
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- wingoz trey wingo
Ok @ThePigskinArch ...you asked for it. http://t.co/BowB5ozS
about 7 hours ago
- wingoz trey wingo

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
Certainly risky if #Packers couldn't find someone for Flynn trade, but I tend to think they could get at least a 3rd rounder worst case
about 7 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Asked @JermichaelF88 if he was happy with the deal. Got message back: "Yessir!"
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
If make room to Franchise Flynn, it would be to trade him...Cassel type deal. Maybe make handshake agreement with Wells
about 7 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
Finley reported average of $7.5M for two years. TE Franchise tag projected at $5.5M; WR Tag projected at $9.5M. Makes sense.
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk
RT @ESPNNewYork: Giants Super Bowl Wallpaper: Eli Manning Edition http://t.co/lH2BGU8n #NYG
about 7 hours ago
- NotoriousOHM Ohm Youngmisuk

- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
J Finley signs with #Packers Now Franchise Flynn?
about 7 hours ago
- WilliamsonNFL Matt Williamson
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
RT @JermichaelF88: It's TRUE! Thank you so much to the Packers organization, all of my fans, and my beautiful wife. Let's GO Packers!!
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter
After striking a deal with TE Jermichael Finley, Packers now can use their franchise tag elsewhere if they so choose.
about 7 hours ago
- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt
2-year deal for @JermichaelF88 good for both sides. JF avoids under-market Tag; FA again at age 26. Packers could not lose key weapon.
about 7 hours ago
- adbrandt Andrew Brandt

- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter
Packers reached agreement with TE Jermichael Finley on a 2-year, $15 million deal.
about 7 hours ago
- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter

- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter
If you were looking for a free-agent running back, which of these would you want to sign? http://t.co/d4GNcfDt
about 8 hours ago
- AdamSchefter Adam Schefter
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- Horton: Biggest NFC offseason needs | AFC
- FBO: Biggest hole for every NFL team
- Verhei: Top NFL franchise tag candidates
- Joyner: Jermichael Finley's value is inflated
- 2012 NFL draft: Big Board | McShay: Top 32

FOLLOW THE NFL ON TWITTER
