Breaking down the DPOY race
Should J.J. Watt, Von Miller or someone else win the award?
It's hard to remember a season such as the one we're witnessing that had these kinds of standout defensive performances in the NFL. We're seeing some truly tremendous displays that are redefining the way we view positions, the upshot being that our PFF grading system is giving out some of the highest marks we've ever seen.
While that's something to celebrate, it means picking a defensive player of the year is extremely difficult. It means we have to go beyond the big box score numbers that are trumpeted by many as the deciding factors in a player's candidacy.
Let's run through the contenders, looking at pros and cons for each player:
The Front-Runners: J.J. Watt and Von Miller
Let me be clear: If these two aren't the first guys you're mentioning for this award, you aren't watching enough football. Break them down however you want; they're on another level right now.
To read more about the defensive player of the year candidates and get access to all of Insider's NFL coverage, sign up today.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- Romo has surgery on back cyst, out 3 weeks
- Bills' Williams denies contemplating suicide
- Sources: NFL close to shifting draft to May
- Gronkowski has 4th surgery on left forearm
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
NFL WEEK 14 COVERAGE

Fantasy Football on ESPN.com
NFL Nation blog | Leaders NFL Stadium Guides | QBR ratings
Playoff Machine | MONDAY NIGHT HQ
TRAGEDY IN DALLAS
MNF: Texans at Patriots, 8:30 ET
- Kuharsky vs. Walker: Texans-Pats debate
- Kuharsky: How do franchises compare?
- Stats & Info: Who has rushing edge?
- Bruschi: Matchup worth the hype
- Reiss: Brady welcomes aggression
WEEK 14 PICKS
POWER RANKINGS
- Shakeup among top 10
- How they voted | Bloggers | Rank 'Em
- Playoffs Predictor: Skins closing in
- Bettors' Poll: Patriots still No. 1
- Sando, Fox
| Mike & Mike 
CLAYTON / FOX / SCHEFTER
- Fox: What does future hold for Vick?
- Schefter: If Wilson weren't a Seahawk
- Clayton's First & 10: No. 1 seeds devalued
- Schefter's Mailbag: Who'll win NFC East?

- Clayton's Mailbag: Teams that fell flat in '12
- Clayton's Last Call: Steelers still in it
- Fox: Flacco's flaws should alarm Ravens
COMMENTARY/ANALYSIS
- Fleming: 10 postgame handshakes to watch
- Grantland: Who's the Most Valuable Person?
- Bryant: Mixed messages on health, safety
- Yasinskas: Resilience defines Falcons
- Graziano: Burden is on Coughlin, Eli
- Sando's MVP Watch: Rookie QBs in focus
- Hensley: Time to take the Bengals seriously
- Seifert: 'Fail Mary' changes NFC playoff race
- Knee-jerk Reactions: 32 strong opinions
INSIDER
- Scouts: Week 14 game by game previews

- Kiper: What work do Lions need?

- Yates: Unleash Kaepernick

- Sprow: Five possible fits for Vick

- Jaworski: Who tops QB ratings?

- Horton: Can the Bucs make the playoffs?

- FBO: Is Atlanta's window closing?

- PFF: Ranking the best and worst O-lines

- FBO: Who's on Week 14 upset watch?

- Keating: NFL's best (and worst) QB values

- Rookie Watch: Blackmon's blossoming

- Edwards: The NFL's most versatile players

- Joyner: Potential RB keepers for 2013

2013 NFL DRAFT
EDITORS' PICKS

- C'mon, NFL, Take The Leap
- Super Bowl L should be for Lambeau Field. Ashley Fox »

- Putting Heads Together
- Owners are still trying to fix the Pro Bowl. Clayton's mailbag »

- The Smarter Money?
- Patient teams might get more bang for their bucks. Clayton »

- Tackling His Demons
- For Rolando McClain, retiring was a smart move. Chadiha »

- Bigger, Stronger ... Faster?
- DT Louis Nix III has a rare combo of size and speed. Index page »
- Horton: How Eagles adapt to Kelly's scheme
- Millman: 2013 NFL win total picks
- Tuley: Best early-season win-total bets
- Red Flags: NFC East | North | South | West
- Kiper: 2014 Big Board | Top TEs | OLBs | ILBs

