Breaking down the DPOY race

Should J.J. Watt, Von Miller or someone else win the award?

Originally Published: December 5, 2012
By Khaled Elsayed | Pro Football Focus
J.J. Watt and Von MillerIcon SMI, AP PhotoJ.J. Watt and Von Miller both have had terrific seasons on the defensive side of the ball.

It's hard to remember a season such as the one we're witnessing that had these kinds of standout defensive performances in the NFL. We're seeing some truly tremendous displays that are redefining the way we view positions, the upshot being that our PFF grading system is giving out some of the highest marks we've ever seen.

While that's something to celebrate, it means picking a defensive player of the year is extremely difficult. It means we have to go beyond the big box score numbers that are trumpeted by many as the deciding factors in a player's candidacy.

Let's run through the contenders, looking at pros and cons for each player:

The Front-Runners: J.J. Watt and Von Miller

Let me be clear: If these two aren't the first guys you're mentioning for this award, you aren't watching enough football. Break them down however you want; they're on another level right now.


To read more about the defensive player of the year candidates and get access to all of Insider's NFL coverage, sign up today.