Commentary
The NFL's irreplaceable players
Peyton Manning, Ware top list of essential stars
Originally Published: June 19, 2009
By
Bill Barnwell | Football Outsiders
In the NFL, star players are considered irreplaceable until proved otherwise. Take Tom Brady: The 2007 NFL MVP would've topped any list of the most irreplaceable players in football this time last year, but by the end of the season, Matt Cassel was considered to be an adequate impersonation of the guy who had put up the best season of any quarterback in NFL history.
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Bill Barnwell (@billbarnwell) is a staff writer for Grantland.
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- Bills' Williams denies contemplating suicide
- Sources: NFL close to shifting draft to May
- Gronkowski has 4th surgery on left forearm
- Fans buy items on RG III's wedding registry
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
FOOTBALL OUTSIDERS ON ESPN INSIDER
With the Super Bowl in the books, Football Outsiders starts looking ahead to 2010 and the biggest issues every NFL team will be facing.
- Denver Broncos: What went wrong in the second half?
- Kansas City Chiefs: Can the Chiefs actually run the 3-4?
- Oakland Raiders: Can anyone here play quarterback?
- San Diego Chargers: What's happening at running back?
- Arizona Cardinals: Can Matt Leinart be the team's QB -- and does the team even have a choice?
- St. Louis Rams: How patient should fans be with the rebuilding process?
- San Francisco 49ers : What can stop this team from contending?
- Seattle Seahawks: Do the Seahawks really have three first-round picks in 2010?
- Baltimore Ravens: Is there trouble ahead for the Baltimore defense?
- Cincinnati Bengals: Will the Bengals complete a forward pass in 2010?
- Cleveland Browns: Who is running things here?
- Pittsburgh Steelers: Are the Steelers still the Steelers?
- Chicago Bears: Can Mike Martz save the Bears offense?
- Detroit Lions: Is Matthew Stafford ready to take the next step?
- Green Bay Packers: Is the Green Bay pass defense good enough to get to the Super Bowl?
- Minnesota Vikings: Will the Vikings aging Pro-Bowler retire or return?
- Buffalo Bills: How does this team fit its personnel into a 3-4 defense?
- Miami Dolphins: Can Mike Nolan do for this team what he did for the 2009 Denver Broncos?
- New England Patriots: Can the Pats come to an agreement with Vince Wilfork?
- New York Jets: Will the defense be as good in 2010?
- Dallas Cowboys: Can the team keep up its run of injury luck?
- New York Giants: Can Perry Fewell fix this defense?
- Philadelphia Eagles: Which direction should the team go at QB?
- Washington Redskins: What type of situation did Mike Shanahan walk into here?
- Houston Texans: Can Steve Slaton bounce back?
- Indianapolis Colts: Can the Colts fix their running game?
- Jacksonville Jaguars: What are the Jags doing at quarterback?
- Tennessee Titans: Can Tennessee rebuild their defense?
- Atlanta Falcons: Can Jamaal Anderson step up on defense?
- Carolina Panthers: Is it time to rebuild?
- New Orleans Saints: Does Darren Sharper deserve the franchise tag?
- Tampa Bay Buccaneers: How does this team help Josh Freeman develop?
- Horton: How Eagles adapt to Kelly's scheme
- Millman: 2013 NFL win total picks
- Tuley: Best early-season win-total bets
- Red Flags: NFC East | North | South | West
- Kiper: 2014 Big Board | Top TEs | OLBs | ILBs


