Commentary
What it takes to succeed as a college quarterback
Originally Published: August 28, 2007
By
Todd McShay | Scouts Inc.
The following is a breakdown of the eight categories (size excluded) we use when evaluating college quarterbacks. Also included in each category are, in my opinion, the top three examples in college football today.
1. JUDGMENT/MENTAL CAPACITY
Best three examples:
1. Brian Brohm, Louisville (Sr.)
2. Colt McCoy, Texas (So.)
3. Chad Henne, Michigan (Sr.)
There are several levels of critical judgments that must be made by a quarterback on each play. It begins with presnap reads, which includes blitz pickup, coverage recognition and possible audibles at the line of scrimmage. It extends to reading coverage on drops, avoiding throws into double coverage and getting the ball to the open receiver. Finally, deciding when to tuck the ball and run, take a sack or throw the ball away factor into the equation.
Best three examples:
1. Brian Brohm, Louisville (Sr.)
2. Colt McCoy, Texas (So.)
3. Chad Henne, Michigan (Sr.)
There are several levels of critical judgments that must be made by a quarterback on each play. It begins with presnap reads, which includes blitz pickup, coverage recognition and possible audibles at the line of scrimmage. It extends to reading coverage on drops, avoiding throws into double coverage and getting the ball to the open receiver. Finally, deciding when to tuck the ball and run, take a sack or throw the ball away factor into the equation.
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
- ESPN College Football and NFL Draft Analyst
- Joined ESPN in 2006
- Played quarterback in high school and was a backup QB for the University of Richmond.
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- Sources: Oklahoma St. limits QB Lunt's options
- For Irish, may be BCS or bust for bowl spot
- Saban: 'Devil' words 'terribly disappointing'
- Running back Richardson will leave Virginia
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
2007 College Football Preview
The long wait for the start of the 2007 college football season is finally over. Get ready for the season with an in-depth look at the teams, trends, players and coaches. Index
Features
• Forde: Arkansas' favorite son also rising
• Forde: Welcome to Trickeration Nation
• Albright: Glanville has Portland State all shook up
• Maisel: Boise State part of quiet revolution
• Edwards: BCS system needs update ![]()
• Forde: QBs face burden of proof in '07
• Schlabach: Biggest shoes to fill this season
• Maisel: (Southern) State of the Game
• Schlabach: Hot or Not for 2007
• Ivan Maisel's preseason All-America team
• Heisman Watch: Voters go Hog wild
• SportsNation: Rank the Heisman contenders Fearless Forecasts
• Experts: Conference title projections
• Maisel/Schlabach: Bowl predictions
• McShay: Don't sleep on these teams
• Games to watch: National | Conference Campus Confidential
• Forde: Woodson stepping out of the shadow
• Schlabach: Shhhh! Uncovering 2007's secrets
• McShay: Seven secrets from the film room
• Feldman: Saturday's secret agents revealed
• EA Sports: Trick play simulations
• Arkansas: Wildhog formation

• Boise State: Statue of Liberty

• LSU: Flea flicker

• Texas: Wide receiver pass

• USC: Halfback pass
ACC Features• Schlabach: ACC needs quality Miami, FSU
• Schlabach: Wright, Freeman still battling at Miami
• Schlabach: Wake sets bar high for encore
• Schlabach: Five ACC predictions Big East Features
• Maisel: What's next for the Big East?
• Maisel: USF's QB exudes old school cool
• Maisel: Five Big East predictions Big Ten Features
• Schlabach: Michigan seniors return on a mission
• Schlabach: Downsized Hill means supersized play
• Schlabach: Big Ten at the crossroads
• Schlabach: Five Big Ten predictions Pac-10 Features
• Forde: Now is the time for UCLA
• Forde: Five Pac-10 predictions
• Maisel: After long wait, Turner ready for stardom
• Maisel: Ten Little Trojans running backs
• Feldman: DeSean Jackson's born identity
• Maisel: Saban snapshot reveals double feature
• Higgins: Spurrier, Gamecocks thinking big
• Schlabach: SEC balance of power shifts East
• Schlabach: Five SEC predictions Coaching Corner
• Schlabach: Coaches on the hot seat
• Schlabach: Rise of the assistants
• McShay: Assistant coaches on the rise
• McShay: Position coaches who deliver
• Kickoffs, timing rules highlight changes
• McShay: Changes put premium on specialists
• College Football Live: Impact of kickoff rule

• Joe Tiller: Kickoff changes raise safety issues

• College Football Live: Matter of time
Campus CallESPN.com will hit eight practice sessions to get an early pulse on the season. Check out what's happening on campus.
• Aug. 7: Gators looking for bite on D
• Aug. 6: ND's Weis plays respect card |
McKnight makes USC debut
• Aug. 5: Brown resolute in face of Texas' troubles
• Aug. 4: WVU has speed to burn
• Aug. 3: Taylor made Jacket
• Aug. 2: Hokies begin road back to normalcy
• Aug. 1: Report day is still a thrill for Tuberville
- Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
- Recruiting: Michigan tops 2014 class ranks
- Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
- Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
- Fremeau: Who will win the SEC? | Pac-12


