The five keys to Florida vs. Alabama
Analyzing the last 12 battles between top-5 defenses shows what will win in Atlanta
When the No. 1 Florida Gators and No. 2 Alabama Crimson Tide face off for both the SEC title and (logically) a bid in the BCS Championship Game, two of the nation's three best defenses will take the field. In terms of Football Outsiders' main college measures, Florida's defense ranks first in both Defensive S&P+ and Defensive FEI, while Alabama ranks third in both.
In the past five seasons, top-5 defenses (according to Defensive S&P+) have faced each other 12 times (see the inline table), and while there is occasionally an offensive explosion (USC scored 55 on Oklahoma in 2004, while Ohio State and Michigan combined for 81 points in 2006), most of the time these battles produce exactly the type of slugfest you'd expect. Thirteen of the 24 competitors in these games scored fewer than 20 points, while only six scored more than 30. In games in which any sort of easy points -- caused by big offensive plays, turnovers, etc. -- could make the difference, which factors end up most closely determining wins and losses?
To learn about the five statistics you should monitor as you scarf down appetizers during the SEC title game -- and to find out in what percentage of previous meetings of top defenses they've been a deciding factor -- you must be an ESPN Insider.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- Sources: Oklahoma St. limits QB Lunt's options
- For Irish, may be BCS or bust for bowl spot
- Saban: 'Devil' words 'terribly disappointing'
- Running back Richardson will leave Virginia
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
College Football on Insider
Follow the college football season with Insider experts Bruce Feldman, Todd McShay, Mel Kiper and more.
Week 18
- 12/29: Joyner: Evaluating Dan Williams
- 12/29: Muench: TE Graham is solid
- 12/28: Weidl: Bruce Carter stands out
Week 17
- 12/23: Kiper: Regrading the 2009 NFL draft
- 12/22: McShay: 2009 All-Satellite team
- 12/22: Joyner: Evaluating Bruce Campbell
- 12/22: Kiper: Big Board
- 12/21: Weidl: OT Davis continues to impress
Week 16
- 12/18: Mel's Matchups: Bowl edition
- 12/17: BtBB: Guys just off the Big Board
- 12/17: Muench: Campbell has big upside
- 12/16: Kiper: Big Board
- 12/16: McShay: Locker's decision risky
- 12/15: Muench: Okung leads OTs
- 12/15: Heisman Predictor: Epilogue
- 12/15: Joyner: Evaluating Anthony Davis
Week 15
- 12/11: FBO: Why Kelly can succeed at ND
- 12/10: Muench: Texas defense is loaded
- 12/10: BtBB: Workout warriors
- 12/9: McShay: Senior QBs struggling
- 12/8: Muench: Examining the RB class
- 12/8: Joyner: Evaluating Tim Tebow
- 12/8: Heisman Predictor: McCoy wins
- 12/7: Weidl: Suh's stock continues to rise
- 12/7: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 14
- 12/4: McShay: Draft buzz Week 14
- 12/3: McShay: TE Hernandez is versatile
- 12/2: BtBB: Rise of Clausen, fall of Dunlap
- 12/2: Mag: The four best freshmen RBs
- 12/2: McShay: Haden will be best pro
- 12/1: Heisman Predictor: Looks like McCoy
- 12/1: FBO: Rebuilding the Golden Dome
- 12/1: Muench: Snead should return
- 12/1: Joyner: Evaluating the Big Suh
- 11/30: Weidl: Dunlap cementing status
- 11/30: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 13
- 11/25: McShay: Mallett has potential
- 11/25: BtBB: Evaluating the DT class
- 11/24: Heisman Predictor: Tebow falling
- 11/24: Joyner: Evaluating Rolando McClain
- 11/23: Muench: Suh is a first-round lock
- 11/23: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 12
- 11/20: McShay: Draft buzz for Week 12
- 11/20: Mag: Life of a PSU mascot
- 11/18: Muench: OL Bowman has all the tools
- 11/18: BtBB: The junior jump (or not)
- 11/18: McShay: DE Morgan heads class
- 11/17: Joyner: Trent Williams is overrated
- 11/17: Heisman Predictor: Gerhart rising
- 11/16: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 11
- 11/13: McShay: Draft buzz for Week 11
- 11/12: McShay: Top 5 tight ends
- 11/11: FBO: TCU deserves a title shot
- 11/10: Mag: Bill Curry is building a program
- 11/10: Muench: Gerhart's draft stock rising
- 11/10: Joyner: McCoy is the total package
- 11/10: Heisman Predictor: Down to three
- 11/9: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 10
- 11/4: BtBB: The fall of Taylor Mays
- 11/4: FBO: Offensive plans for LSU, 'Bama
- 11/3: Heisman Predictor: A new favorite
- 11/3: Joyner: Cody shows areas of concern
- 11/2: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Week 9
- 10/29: Muench: Austin faces tough test
- 10/28: BtBB: Dez Bryant's future
- 10/28: FBO: USC defensive flaws
- 10/27: Heisman Predictor: McCoy's move
- 10/26: Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
Weeks 5-8
- 10/22: FBO: Home-field advantages
- 10/21: Roenigk: Dealing with injuries
- 10/20: Joyner: PSU's Bowman needs work
- 10/20: Heisman Predictor: Tebow/Ingram
- 10/19 Stock Reports: McShay | Kiper
- 10/19: Draft blog: Bradford is falling
- 10/19: Feldman: Ingram for Heisman
- 10/19: FBO: The best one-loss teams
- 10/15: Mel's Matchups: Red River watch
- 10/14: Shurburtt: ND's recruiting weekend
- 10/14: McShay: Top OU/Texas prospects
- 10/14: BtBB: Suh and McCoy
- 10/13: Heisman Predictor: Clausen's chance
- 10/12: Kiper: Breakthrough for Graham
- 10/6: Heisman Predictor: The Pike position
- 10/5: Kiper: Why scouts like Spiller
- 10/5: McShay: Clausen's stock climbing
- 10/1: Mel's Matchups: OU-UM battles
- 9/29: Heisman Predictor: Forcier rising up
- 9/29: Mag: TSU as Second Chance U
Weeks 1-4
- 9/23 McShay: Tebow misses big chance
- 9/23: FBO: Surprise or sham teams
- 9/22: Heisman Predictor: Best rises in West
- 9/21: Kiper: Orakpo's heir and Locker's rise
- 9/20: Feldman: Sark's big day in Seattle
- 9/16: FBO: BYU's shot at undefeated
- 9/15: Heisman Predictor: A two-man race?
- 9/14: Kiper: Berry upstaged vs. UCLA
- 9/10: Kiper: Key matchups for 9/12/09
- 9/10: Feldman: Eric Berry - Safety First
- 9/10: McShay: Film room: Terrelle Pryor
- 9/8: Heisman Predictor: A fresh contender?
- 9/7: McShay: Stock Watch: Clausen Up
- 9/3: McShay: Film room: Tight Ends
- 9/3: Kiper: Key matchups for 9/5/09
- 8/20: BtBB: Snead over McCoy?
- Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
- Recruiting: Michigan tops 2014 class ranks
- Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
- Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
- Fremeau: Who will win the SEC? | Pac-12

