Andrew Luck is as 'can't-miss' as it gets 

April, 29, 2011
04/29/11
1:03
PM ET

Plenty of NFL draft talk to lead this week's mailbag:

From @edavis19: On a scale of one to infinity, how good is Andrew Luck?

There is no such thing as a "can't-miss" NFL prospect. If I had to name the guys closest to that label in the past two years, I'd go with Eric Berry and Patrick Peterson. However, I will say this: Luck is the most complete quarterback prospect that has come along in the past decade. He is brilliant, plays in a pro-style system and was well-coached. He has great size; a powerful, accurate arm; very good agility; and, as Jim Harbaugh once told me, he's "got memory talent."

Harbaugh, who clearly knows what it takes to play in the NFL, was gushing over a guy who had never played in a game at the time, and in a way I'd never heard a coach talk about an unproven QB. It was even stronger praise than when Pete Carroll talked about Matt Barkley.

Well, Harbaugh was spot-on. Luck also has "it." The problem is excelling as a QB in the NFL is never certain for anyone. So much is dependent on the timing and the situation. I suspect Aaron Rodgers would have still emerged as a great NFL quarterback if the 49ers had drafted him rather than Alex Smith, but you never know. Smith, the first overall pick, was a player everyone praised for his intelligence, athleticism and youth, but he didn't have the arm, the pocket presence or the advantage of having been developed in a pro-style system in college like Luck has. He also has played for about 19 different offensive coordinators since coming to San Francisco, which could be a big reason why he's struggled.

That said, if I had to use a No. 1 overall draft pick on any college quarterback, Luck would be my choice. The others I would bypass, because it's just too big of a risk, seeing as how taking the wrong quarterback can set your franchise back five years and get a lot of people fired.


To read the rest of Bruce Feldman's mailbag, including other draft questions and Bruce's take on Alabama's national title chances, become an ESPN Insider today.

SPONSORED HEADLINES