Overrating Josh Johnson
No. 30 on ESPN 500 might not be most valuable pitcher on his own team
On today's list of the No. 26-50 players in baseball according to the ESPN 500, Miami Marlins ace Josh Johnson came in at No. 30, one spot behind fellow sometimes-injured starter Chris Carpenter. It's easy to see why Johnson (and Carpenter, for that matter) ranked so highly, as they are dominating starters when they take the mound.
Johnson's career ERA- is 70, meaning he has prevented runs at a rate 30 percent better than an average pitcher in that time. To put that in perspective, Roy Halladay's career ERA- is 71. On a per-inning basis, Johnson stacks up favorably against any pitcher in the game.
To read the full story and get access to all of ESPN Insider's daily MLB content, sign up and become an Insider.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Dave Cameron
FanGraphs- Managing editor of FanGraphs
- Founder of U.S.S. Mariner
- Also contributes to Wall Street Journal
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE MLB HEADLINES
- Brewers closer Henderson out for hamstring
- Yankees rally, win on Overbay's HR in 11th
- Giants win on Pagan's inside-the-park HR
- Granderson fractures pinkie after hit by pitch
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
TOP 500 MLB PLAYERS OF 2012

Follow the top 500 rankings and join the discussion on Facebook and Twitter (@ESPN_MLB) at #ESPN500.
RANKINGS SCHEDULE
Tuesday, March 20
Players ranked Nos. 401-500
· Triple Play: Surprises among bottom 100 »
· Video: Who could break out? »
· Szymborski: The next Jose Bautista? »
· Video: Who Kurkjian likes in 'bottom' 100 »
Wednesday, March 21
Players ranked Nos. 351-400
· Triple Play: Is Dunn done? »
· Video: Slumping sluggers »
Thursday, March 22
Players ranked Nos. 301-350
· BP: Underrated by ballpark »
· Triple Play: Top 100 in 2013? »
· Video: Youngsters to watch »
Friday, March 23
Players ranked Nos. 251-300
· Triple Play: No love for R.A. Dickey? »
· BBTN Video: Zambrano & names to note »
Monday, March 26
Players ranked Nos. 201-250
· Cameron: Top 500's underachievers »
· Triple Play: Helton for Hall of Fame? »
· Video: Bowden & Stark on Cuban duo »
Tuesday, March 27
Players ranked Nos. 151-200
· Triple Play: Who's listed too high? »
· Law: Who'll be No. 1 in 2017 »
· Video: Law/Schoenfield on three rookies »
Wednesday, March 28
Players ranked Nos. 101-150
· Triple Play: Is Jeter still elite? »
· Schoenfield: Jeter's year-to-year rank »
· Video: BBTN on Jeter at No. 115 »
Thursday, March 29
Players ranked Nos. 51-100
· Triple Play: Strasburg, Andrus worthy? »
· Insider: Phillies' age issue »
· Video: Darvish, Strasburg or Moore? »
Friday, March 30
Players ranked Nos. 26-50
· Triple Play: Moving up, A-Rod's HR pursuit »
· Insider: Is Johnson the Marlins' best P? »
· Video: McCutchen or Stanton? »
Monday, April 2
Players ranked Nos. 11-25
· Triple Play: Is Mo too high, who's too low? »
· Insider: Who are the top gloves? »
· Video: BBTN on Mariano Rivera at No. 12 »
Tuesday, April 3
Players ranked Nos. 1-10
· Breakdowns by team/position »
· Insider: Most over- or underrated? »
· Triple Play: Did the voters get it right?
· Video: BBTN on Pujols as No. 1 »
TEAM-BY-TEAM RANKINGS
Check out where players ranked on each team:
- MLB Draft: NL Central targets
- Olney: Scanning the bullpen market
- Szymborski: Best in-house upgrades
- Cameron: Lackey's first-pitch success
- Law: Diagnosing Hosmer, Moustakas' woes

