Yankees shouldn't rush Banuelos
The promising prospect needs more time to develop in the minor leagues
With the hype machine firing on all cylinders, New York Yankees phenom Manny Banuelos took the mound on Monday night in a nationally televised game against the big league lineup of the Boston Red Sox just one day after his 20th birthday. While he struggled with his command at times, he was otherwise worthy of the praise he's been receiving, as he showcased well above-average velocity and an outstanding changeup that generated silly-looking swings from two of Boston's best hitters: Dustin Pedroia and Kevin Youkilis. One scout watching the game said he was tempted to put an 80, the highest possible score, on the pitch.
With the Yankees' rotation in more than a bit of flux, the calls from fans for Banuelos to be part of the immediate solution continue. He'll make at least one more appearance with the big league team, likely on Saturday, but he's going to the minors after that, and it's the right decision for the Yankees long term.
Twenty-year-old starting pitchers in the big leagues are rarities, but having a player like Banuelos, who has made just three starts above Class-A ball, in the big leagues would be nearly unprecedented. Seventeen pitchers this decade have come up as starters prior to their 21st birthday, and the one constant among them was a full workload the previous year, as they averaged more than 140 innings in the year prior to their debuts, with all 17 pitching at least 100 frames. In addition, only three of the 17 -- CC Sabathia (2001), Jeremy Bonderman (2003) and Rick Porcello (2009) -- opened their debut year in the majors, with the remaining 14 averaging more than 100 minor league innings in the season they first got the call.
Make no mistake about it, Banuelos could at the very least hold his own in the big leagues right now, but the real question revolves around how long he could do it.
To read why the Yankees should wait to bring up Banuelos, despite their problems in the rotation, you must be an ESPN Insider.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE MLB HEADLINES
- Yanks' Kuroda hit in calf with liner, later leaves
- Nats' closer calls out Harper's OF positioning
- Canseco accused of sexual assault in Vegas
- Cards' Garica (shoulder) headed for surgery
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
Insider MLB Content

WEEK OF OCT. 30 
Nov. 5: Bowden: Grading the Jim Thome dealNov. 5: Law: Thome, Phillies aren't a great fit
Nov. 4: Bowden: Pricing the free agents
Nov. 3: Law: Ranking top 50 MLB free agents
Nov. 2: Jedlovec: Worst Gold Glove selections
Nov. 1: Meyers: Buyer beware of C.J. Wilson
Oct. 31: Cameron: Papi a fit in the Bronx
Oct. 30: Perry: Finding free agency solutions
Oct. 30: Szymborski: St. Louis without Pujols
WEEK OF OCT. 16 
Oct. 28: Law: Chapman still needs workOct. 26: BP: Batter-pitcher data is overrated
Oct. 24: FanGraphs: A blueprint for C.J. Wilson
Oct. 21: Cameron: Cards should bench Berkman
Oct. 20: BP: Why did Washington walk Punto?
Oct. 19: Szymborski: Sims favor the Rangers
Oct. 18: Bowden: Ranking all 50 WS players
Oct. 18: Jedlovec: Previewing WS defenses
Oct. 17: Perry: World Series hinges on relief
Oct. 16: Szymborski: Milwaukee without Fielder
Oct. 16: FanGraphs: Brewers' NLCS miscues
KISS 'EM GOODBYE 
Oct. 30: St. Louis CardinalsOct. 29: Texas Rangers
Oct. 18: Milwaukee Brewers
Oct. 17: Detroit Tigers
Oct. 8: Arizona Diamondbacks
Oct. 8: Philadelphia Phillies
Oct. 7: New York Yankees
Oct. 5: Tampa Bay Rays
Sept. 29: Atlanta Braves
Sept. 29: Boston Red Sox
Sept. 27: Los Angeles Angels
Sept. 26: San Francisco Giants
Sept. 25: Cleveland Indians
Sept. 24: Chicago White Sox
Sept. 23: Oakland A's
Sept. 22: Los Angeles Dodgers
Sept. 21: Colorado Rockies
Sept. 20: Toronto Blue Jays
Sept. 19: Cincinnati Reds
Sept. 18: San Diego Padres
Sept. 17: Pittsburgh Pirates
Sept. 16: Kansas City Royals
Sept. 15: Minnesota Twins
Sept. 14: New York Mets
Sept. 13: Washington Nationals
Sept. 12: Seattle Mariners
Sept. 11: Chicago Cubs
Sept. 10: Baltimore Orioles
Sept. 9: Florida Marlins
Sept. 8: Houston Astros
ESSENTIAL LINKS 
Buster Olney's Blog
Daily insight from around the majors
MLB Rumor Central
Get news and rumblings before anyone
Updated top 50 prospects (7/15)
MLB Draft Blog
The 2012 draft prospect watch is well underway.
Keith Law's Blog
Everything prospects, baseball ruminations
Eric Karabell Blog
Fantasy advice, every day, all season
- Olney: Miggy eyes another Triple Crown
- Cameron: Top early-season turnarounds
- Petriello: Quiet winter doesn't slow Texas
- Spratt: Goldschmidt setting MVP pace
- Law: Appel not No. 1 in mock draft

