Braun deal a mistake
The Brewers left fielder is a star, but the club already had him locked up for his prime
In a surprise move, the Milwaukee Brewers signed Ryan Braun to a five-year extension of his current contract, keeping him in town through age 36 at an additional cost of $105 million.
If anything, Braun's extension seals the deal on Prince Fielder's departure at the end of the season. The Brewers, while a much more successful franchise than during the years Bud Selig owned the team, are unlikely to want to commit nearly $50 million a year for two players for half a decade, years ahead of time.
The Brewers made the right decision in choosing Braun over Fielder. While Fielder's one of the most feared sluggers in baseball, it's hard to see a player with his frame aging gracefully in his 30s.
However, the Brewers probably made a mistake here as this wasn't a contract that the team needed to sign. It does tell the fan base that the team's not going to give up on signing its own players, but a nine-figure commitment is a pricy way to do this.
For a full explanation of why the Ryan Braun deal is bad for the Brewers, you must be an ESPN Insider.
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Dan Szymborski
ESPN Insider- Creator of ZiPS projection system
- Founder of Baseball Think Factory
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE MLB HEADLINES
- Shoulder strain sends Cardinals' Garcia to DL
- Braves' O'Flaherty has torn ligament in elbow
- Ortiz has 2 HRs, 6 RBIs as Red Sox cruise
- Andrus enjoys 5-hit night as Rangers top Tigers
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
Insider MLB Content

WEEK OF OCT. 30 
Nov. 5: Bowden: Grading the Jim Thome dealNov. 5: Law: Thome, Phillies aren't a great fit
Nov. 4: Bowden: Pricing the free agents
Nov. 3: Law: Ranking top 50 MLB free agents
Nov. 2: Jedlovec: Worst Gold Glove selections
Nov. 1: Meyers: Buyer beware of C.J. Wilson
Oct. 31: Cameron: Papi a fit in the Bronx
Oct. 30: Perry: Finding free agency solutions
Oct. 30: Szymborski: St. Louis without Pujols
WEEK OF OCT. 16 
Oct. 28: Law: Chapman still needs workOct. 26: BP: Batter-pitcher data is overrated
Oct. 24: FanGraphs: A blueprint for C.J. Wilson
Oct. 21: Cameron: Cards should bench Berkman
Oct. 20: BP: Why did Washington walk Punto?
Oct. 19: Szymborski: Sims favor the Rangers
Oct. 18: Bowden: Ranking all 50 WS players
Oct. 18: Jedlovec: Previewing WS defenses
Oct. 17: Perry: World Series hinges on relief
Oct. 16: Szymborski: Milwaukee without Fielder
Oct. 16: FanGraphs: Brewers' NLCS miscues
KISS 'EM GOODBYE 
Oct. 30: St. Louis CardinalsOct. 29: Texas Rangers
Oct. 18: Milwaukee Brewers
Oct. 17: Detroit Tigers
Oct. 8: Arizona Diamondbacks
Oct. 8: Philadelphia Phillies
Oct. 7: New York Yankees
Oct. 5: Tampa Bay Rays
Sept. 29: Atlanta Braves
Sept. 29: Boston Red Sox
Sept. 27: Los Angeles Angels
Sept. 26: San Francisco Giants
Sept. 25: Cleveland Indians
Sept. 24: Chicago White Sox
Sept. 23: Oakland A's
Sept. 22: Los Angeles Dodgers
Sept. 21: Colorado Rockies
Sept. 20: Toronto Blue Jays
Sept. 19: Cincinnati Reds
Sept. 18: San Diego Padres
Sept. 17: Pittsburgh Pirates
Sept. 16: Kansas City Royals
Sept. 15: Minnesota Twins
Sept. 14: New York Mets
Sept. 13: Washington Nationals
Sept. 12: Seattle Mariners
Sept. 11: Chicago Cubs
Sept. 10: Baltimore Orioles
Sept. 9: Florida Marlins
Sept. 8: Houston Astros
ESSENTIAL LINKS 
Buster Olney's Blog
Daily insight from around the majors
MLB Rumor Central
Get news and rumblings before anyone
Updated top 50 prospects (7/15)
MLB Draft Blog
The 2012 draft prospect watch is well underway.
Keith Law's Blog
Everything prospects, baseball ruminations
Eric Karabell Blog
Fantasy advice, every day, all season
- Law: First 2013 mock draft
- Bowden: Who's better -- Miller or Harvey?
- Nitkowski: MLB clubs now smarter in Asia
- Karabell: Machado deserves more love
- Szymborski: Astros' quest to catch '62 Mets
