BP Daily: Baseball's irreplaceable stars
Alex Rodriguez not among the 10 toughest players to replace
When the news on Alex Rodriguez's hip injury broke last week, the Baseball Prospectus crew brainstormed a few possible solutions for the Yankees. Unsurprisingly, we reached an inevitable conclusion: He's virtually irreplaceable, at least when it comes to finding a player under team control who could offset the expected loss of production.
Bound for surgery, Rodriguez is projected to miss six to nine weeks. Barring a trade, his most likely in-house replacement is 33-year-old journeyman Cody Ransom, whose solid .251/.348/.432 line over the course of 214 major league plate appearances spread across six seasons is dwarfed by a lengthy, significantly less impressive minor league track record which drags down his PECOTA weighted mean projection to a brutal .216/.293/.386 line and a -0.164 Marginal Lineup Value rate, the number of runs per game he would contribute (or cost) to a lineup of otherwise average offensive performers. By comparison, Rodriguez is forecast for 0.174 MLVr, a difference of 0.338 runs per game. That's 10 runs -- or roughly one additional win -- for every 29.6 games, or 54.8 runs over the course of 162 games.
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
BASEBALL PROSPECTUS ON ESPN INSIDER
Baseball Prospectus brings its unique brand of baseball analysis to ESPN Insider.
Week of Sept. 7
- Sept. 10: On young pitchers and workloads
- Sept. 9: The Giants' giant offensive problem
- Sept. 8: Pirates' prospects offer little hope
Week of Aug. 31
- Sept. 4: Derek Jeter's future
- Sept. 3: Velocity is key for pitchers
- Sept. 2: The AL owns the NL
- Sept. 1: Tommy Hanson's hot start
- Aug. 31: Predicting the MVPs
Week of Aug. 24
- Aug. 28: NL contenders' schedule strength
- Aug. 27: AL contenders' schedule strength
- Aug. 25: Alex Gordon's Royal problem
- Aug. 24: Billy Wagner can help Boston
Week of Aug. 17
- Aug. 21: The future of Mark Reynolds
- Aug. 19: Pujols and the Triple Crown
- Aug. 18: The Nats' path to relevance
- Aug. 17: The re-education of J.J. Hardy
Week of Aug. 10
- Aug. 14: Misfiring young guns
- Aug. 11: Helton and the Hall of Fame
- Aug. 10: Alex Rios' value to the White Sox
- Aug. 10: Ryan Braun and position changes
Week of Aug. 3
- Aug. 6: Yanks and Sox still need pitching
- Aug. 5: Potential waiver-wire deals
- Aug. 4: How the Indians got this bad
- Aug. 3: Sorting out the playoff odds now
Baseball Prospectus Archive
- Rumors: Comeback kids and FA updates
- Olney: Red Sox have MLB's best rotation
- Law: Top organizations | Prospect rankings
- Arangure: Francisco Liriano's big winter
