Commentary

Keith Law's top 50 free agents

Prince Fielder and Albert Pujols head a top-heavy free-agent class

Originally Published: November 3, 2011
By Keith Law | ESPN Insider
Prince Fielder, Albert PujolesJeff Curry/Getty ImagesPrince Fielder, left, and Albert Pujols create runs, but Pujols saves them, too.

For the sixth straight year, Keith Law breaks down the top 50 free agents, this time for the class of 2011-12. Law's reports are based on firsthand observation. He has been the senior baseball analyst for Scouts Inc. since 2006. Before joining ESPN, Law served as special assistant to the general manager of the Toronto Blue Jays and was a writer for Baseball Prospectus.

This free-agent class is one of the thinnest I've ever seen, made thinner by the signing during the closed period of CC Sabathia (originally No. 3 on this list). There are only a few clear high-impact players and a handful of high-risk/high-reward guys, but there's depth in potential average starters in the outfield, in back-end starting pitchers and in the bullpen.

As always, the free-agent class is skewed toward players who are in or soon to enter their decline phase, because the current system keeps them under team control until they've amassed six full years of major league service time (which might be spread out across more than six years). I've mixed in some younger players who hit free agency with question marks unrelated to age (e.g., Grady Sizemore and his multiple surgeries) along with those higher-probability players who project only as fringe starters or bench guys going forward.

Law's complete top 50: 1-10 Insider | 11-30 Insider | 31-50 Insider


For the full list, with player evaluations, you need to be an ESPN Insider.