Georgia is not a top-5 team
Poor all-around defense, other flaws make the Bulldogs overrated so far
One of the main issues many people have with the college football poll rankings is that they rely very heavily on where a team rates in the opening-week poll. Upward mobility in the poll rankings is possible in a general sense, but as long as the teams in the upper tier stay unbeaten, it can be next to impossible to move up from a lower rank and contend for a national championship.
A proposed solution to this issue is to hold off on putting together the first poll until a few weeks of the college football season have been played. Seeing teams in action before ranking them would help ensure the best teams are moved to the top of the list based on their on-field performance rather than on preseason reputation.
If that formula were in effect today, it's possible that the Georgia Bulldogs would still be ranked No. 5 in the AP top 25 after the first five weeks of the season. After all, the Bulldogs did win a tough road contest at Missouri, shellacked a Vanderbilt Commodores squad that gave the South Carolina Gamecocks a battle in Week 1 and won a shootout against a very explosive Tennessee Volunteers offense. Georgia has also set a school record by scoring 40 or more points in five straight games, so it would get some style points as well.
But if we take a closer look at Georgia's metrics and game tape, it is clear that this is a flawed and overrated squad that may barely deserve a top-10 ranking at this moment, let alone top-5.
Let's go through the multitude of areas where the Bulldogs have displayed significant weaknesses.
To read the full story why Georgia is overrated at No. 5, you must be an ESPN Insider.
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- Sources: Oklahoma St. limits QB Lunt's options
- For Irish, may be BCS or bust for bowl spot
- Saban: 'Devil' words 'terribly disappointing'
- Running back Richardson will leave Virginia
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
Insider CFB content
Expert Takes• Kiper: Top prospects for 2014, by position
• Haney: CFB's top 10 teams based on talent
• Kiper: Top QB prospects for 2014 | RBs | WRs
• Haney: Make-or-break QB prospect scenarios
• Joyner: Prospects set for breakout seasons
• Haney: Prospects who can elevate programs
Post-spring projections• Pac-12: Oregon, Stanford, USC on top
• ACC: Can Clemson win the league title?
• SEC: Bama, South Carolina early favorites
• Big Ten: Surprise winner in Legends
• Big 12: Two-team race for first place
RecruitingNation• Michigan No. 1 in 2014 class rankings
• Luginbill: Answering mailbag questions
• Crabtree: Urban recruits popular draft picks
• Notre Dame, Boise State trending up
• Recruiting updates for Pac-12 teams
• Recruiting updates for Big Ten teams
• Recruiting updates for SEC teams
• Recruiting updates for ACC teams
• Recruiting updates for Big East teams
• Recruiting updates for Big 12 teams
Get news and rumblings before anyone
Travis Haney's blog
Analysis and buzz from around the nation