Commentary

The Crimson Tide's Achilles' heel

Alabama has all the pieces of a BCS title team, but can they take care of the ball?

Updated: September 7, 2011, 11:12 AM ET
By Brad Edwards | ESPN Insider
McCarron/SimsUS PresswireAJ McCarron and Phillip Sims threw four total INTs in Week 1. Greg McElroy had four in all of 2009.

The Alabama Crimson Tide entered this season needing to replace five starters from last year's team.

Four of those lost starters were taken in the first round of the NFL draft. The other one, however, might be the most difficult for the Tide to replace in their quest for the 2011 BCS title.

To be clear, Alabama doesn't have another Julio Jones, and it doesn't have another Marcell Dareus. There's a reason those guys were top-10 picks. Bama is looking at a couple of solid options to ultimately fill the vacancy left by James Carpenter at left tackle, and people have been saying for two years that Trent Richardson is every bit as good as Mark Ingram at running back.

But filling the shoes at quarterback might be a different story.

Scouts would tell you that AJ McCarron and Phillip Sims are more physically gifted than Greg McElroy, and they certainly were more highly recruited than their predecessor. But it takes more than height and arm strength to make an effective QB, and failing to match McElroy's success in one critical area could prove problematic for the Tide.


To read more about the one weakness that could derail Alabama's BCS title hopes, become an ESPN Insider today.

• Analyzes college football and the BCS as part of ESPN's Stats & Information Group
• Analyst for both College GameDay on ESPN Radio and the ESPN College Football app