In today’s mailbag, Baylor’s schedule is compared to Ohio State’s, Iowa State fans yearn for the second coming of Bill Snyder and Texas fans want a louder stadium, Tyrone Swoopes at QB and a certain coach to be fired.
To the ‘bag:
Brenna in Stillwater, Okla., writes: It doesn’t seem like anyone is giving Oklahoma State a chance against Baylor. I know you predicted Baylor would win, but do you think the Pokes have a legitimate chance to get the win in convincing fashion?
Jake Trotter: The win, yes. But in convincing fashion? That’s asking a lot. That would require Oklahoma State forcing a bunch of turnovers, which the Cowboys have been terrific at. Problem is, Baylor doesn’t turn the ball over. Bryce Petty has thrown just one interception all year. The Cowboys are more than capable of winning this game. I almost picked them. But I don’t see a scenario in which Baylor gets blown out. That offense is just too good to let that happen.
Isaac in Waukee, Iowa, writes: Aside from hiring their own “Wizard” what needs to happen at Iowa State to reach Kansas State's level of consistent success? They seem to be similar schools with agricultural roots, true college towns, isolated from bigger TV markets.
Trotter: Bill Snyder didn’t build K-State in a day. The Wildcats had only one winning season in Snyder’s first four years. Yes, the Cyclones have taken a step back this year. But Paul Rhoads has proven to be a solid coach, underscored by the fact he took the Cyclones to bowls in three of his four years. Iowa State needs to give him more time. Way more time. Rome wasn’t built in a day. Neither was Manhattan. Neither will Ames.
John in Dramaville writes: So what happens if OU beats K-State, Oklahoma State beats Baylor, Texas Tech beats Texas, Baylor beats TCU, OU beats Oklahoma State and Texas beats Baylor? There would be a four-way tie. Who would get the BCS bowl bid?
Trotter: The same tiebreakers would apply. The first tiebreaker would be the records of the four teams compared against each other. OU would be 1-2. Baylor would be 1-2. Texas would be 2-1. Oklahoma State would be 2-1. But the Cowboys would get the BCS bowl bid, having defeated Texas head-to-head. Thanks for the headache I now have, by the way.
Trotter: Because they aren’t as good as the guys playing. I know OU fans wanted Russell to be the second coming of Tommie Harris, but that was always a pipedream. I tried many times to tell OU fans this. Byrd is a nice prospect, but he’s a true freshman.
Josh Brown in Dallas writes: In all these hypothetical debates about Baylor and Ohio State, I hear a lot about both teams playing a weak schedule. But I never hear about the one team they played in common, Buffalo. Ohio State won 40-20, while Baylor was up 56-13 at HALF! Any reason this doesn't get more attention as it is the obvious best point of comparison?
Trotter: I think a more powerful argument favoring Baylor is this: Ohio State has four road wins over teams (Cal, Illinois, Northwestern, and Purdue) who are a combined 0-26 in league play. Contrast that with a potential road win for Baylor at No. 10 Oklahoma State, and the case would be closed, in my opinion. Of course, the Bears have to win that game first.
James Fulton in El Paso, Texas, writes: Jake, with only two games plus a bowl game left, do you see David Ash sitting out the rest of the season? I assume he is eligible for a redshirt, and can come back as a junior next year.
Trotter: Ash would only be eligible for a medical redshirt if doctors didn’t clear him the rest of the season (sitting him while he’s cleared doesn’t count). But assuming he’s not cleared, which is doesn’t look like he will be, then yes, a medical redshirt is a very good possibility.
Daniel in Houston writes: Let me start by saying I'm one of the biggest Texas fans around. That said, what’s up with the Texas fans at home games? We are by far the quietest fans I've ever seen. Last year Kenny Vaccaro was scrutinized for making similar comments when he was absolutely right. The student section looks like they are AARP members. I honestly can’t get over how quiet it is in DKR. Please help me understand.
Trotter: The people in Austin have higher expectations than what the Longhorns have been delivering. And 9-3 seasons don’t cut it at Texas. They don’t get the fans there fired up, either.
David in Richmond, Va., writes: During the Kansas-West Virginia game, the announcers kept talking about how many West Virginia players were injured. So I have to wonder, how many players are out for each team in the Big 12?
Trotter: I don’t have enough space here to list every injury for every team. But just about every team in the Big 12 has been hit with major injuries. Texas lost Johnathan Gray, David Ash and Chris Whaley. TCU lost Devonte Fields for the year and Casey Pachall for several games. Oklahoma lost Corey Nelson, Jordan Phillips and Trey Millard. Baylor lost Tevin Reese and now Spencer Drango. Oklahoma State lost Devin Davis during the preseason and has been without Josh Stewart. Texas Tech is missing several key defensive players. Iowa State has been beat up offensively pretty much all year. Injuries are part of football, and West Virginia is hardly exclusive to them.
James in Overland Park, Kan., writes: Will Tyrone Swoopes start for Texas against Texas Tech? Also will Mack Brown be fired after the Baylor game?
Trotter: Swoopes could play more, but McCoy is going to get the start. It’s possible that Brown resigns after the Baylor game, but he’s not going to be fired Lane Kiffin style.
Scott in Edgewater, Md., writes: What does Dana Holgorsen have to do to right the ship? Better recruits? More experience? Better coaches? I understand that the Big 12 is not the Big East, and that we have lost Stedman Bailey, Geno Smith and Tavon Austin. But this is getting unacceptable to me. At what point does Holgorsen have to worry about his job?
Trotter: I don’t think Holgorsen is in danger yet, even after that disappointing performance in Lawrence. The man who hired him (Oliver Luck) is still there, and this was always going to be a rebuilding year. But the Mountaineers better show improvement in 2014, or things could get tense real fast in Morgantown.
Josh in Hastings, Neb., writes: Obviously the best bowl scenario for the Big 12 would be for two undefeated teams to lose and Baylor to go to the national title game. But if that doesn’t happen, wouldn’t the best scenario be for Oklahoma State to beat Baylor this week, then for Baylor to win out? Baylor would then be in good position to get a BCS at-large bid. What do you think?
Trotter: The scenario you lay out is the best path for the Big 12 to get two BCS bowl teams. Probably the only way.
Cat in Manhattan, Kan., writes: Any chance we get ranked if we beat OU?
Jake Trotter: Doubtful. K-State is still not receiving any votes for the Top 25. But if the ‘Cats finish the regular season with an 8-4 record and a six-game winning streak, maybe they’ll slip in. They’d definitely be deserving at that point.