Tuesday, June 17, 2014
Take Two: Most compelling RB derby?
By Jake Trotter and Brandon Chatmon
Both OU's Keith Ford and Kansas State's DeMarcus Robinson are unproven and at the forefront of two RB battles.
It's Take Two Tuesday, when we give our opinions on a topic related to the Big 12.
Today's topic: Which is the Big 12’s most compelling running back competition?
Take 1: Brandon Chatmon -- Oklahoma
It will be fun to watch the battle to get the bulk of the carries at Oklahoma.
The Sooners’ running backs room is full of talent, but it’s largely unproven. Sophomore Keith Ford has shown toughness and a physical running style, fellow sophomore Alex Ross has exceptional physical gifts and the Sooners added a pair of true freshmen, Joe Mixon and Samaje Perine, who will be right in the thick of the battle for playing time.
If someone steps up during preseason camp and locks down the job, that would be ideal for the Sooners, but the best-case scenario is two or more running backs forcing the coaches to find a role for them this fall. And that’s not out of the question because Mixon is extremely versatile, Perine brings terrific size, Ross brings size and speed and Ford looks like the most complete back of the group.
Yet, even with all the talent, the Sooners will enter the season with Ford as the most productive returnee after recording 4.6 percent of OU’s total rushing yards (134 rushing yards) as a true freshman. There are unknowns abound at the position from Ford’s fumble troubles to Ross’ inconsistency to the freshmen’s transition into college football.
It could be a boom-or-bust situation. I can’t wait to see it play out in 2014.
Take 2: Jake Trotter -- Kansas State
Brandon opted to go with a running back competition loaded with intriguing options. I’ll go the other way.
The biggest hole on K-State’s roster going into the preseason is at running back. John Hubert manned the position for the Wildcats for the last three years, rushing for 2,965 yards and 28 touchdowns.
His departure has left K-State with virtually no experience returning at running back. DeMarcus Robinson, in fact, is the team’s most seasoned returning rusher with just 11 career carries for 45 yards.
During the spring, neither Robinson nor Jarvis Leverett showed they’re necessarily the answer at the position, making running back the position to watch in Manhattan this August. The rest of the offense appears to be in place. At quarterback, Jake Waters surged the end of last season and was sharp and confident again this spring. Tyler Lockett is one of the best receivers in the country and the offensive line should be stout with All-Big 12 performers BJ Finney and Cody Whitehair.
The Wildcats, however, likely won’t contend for a Big 12 title unless a playmaker emerges at running back.
Robinson and Leverett will get more chances to show what they can do. But so will incoming freshman Dalvin Warmack, who rushed for 4,500 yards and 70 touchdowns and averaged almost 9 yards per carry during his final two years in high school.
If the answer at running back emerges, this K-State offense will be complete. But until that happens, this competition will remain compelling.