For FCS teams, it's about beating the best
Eastern Washington coach Beau Baldwin won a Football Championship Subdivision national title in 2010. Both personally and professionally, he feels a duty to call his team's one-point win against Delaware his finest victory as a coach.
But he also knows how fans work. Their memories can be short, and big names tend to get embedded in their minds.
"Ten or 15 years from now, people might not remember who we beat in the national title game, but they'll remember the ranked team who we beat in the Pac-12," Baldwin said. "It puts you that much more on the map."
Baldwin spoke from a bus carrying happy Eastern Washington players and coaches from Corvallis, Ore., back to their campus in Cheney, Wash., Earlier in the day, Eastern Washington came to Reser Stadium and outlasted No. 25 Oregon State 49-46, recording the first win against a Pac-12 opponent in program history.
The Eagles' win highlighted a huge opening weekend for FCS teams, which brought down Kansas State (North Dakota State), Iowa State (Northern Iowa), San Diego State (Eastern Illinois), South Florida (McNeese State) and Connecticut (Towson), to name a few. The FCS ended up with seven wins against the FBS, which boasts more athletic scholarships (85 versus 63), resources and, of course, home-field advantage.
After falling just short against Washington State last season (a 24-20 loss) and Washington (30-27) in 2011, Eastern Washington finally soared past the big, bad Pac-12. It marked just the third FCS win against a ranked FBS opponent and the first since 2010.
"It's a huge win for the program," Baldwin said. "I won't undersell it. People remember Appalachian State beat Michigan [in 2007]. They can't remember who they beat for three straight [FCS] national titles [in 2005, 2006 and 2007]."
McNeese State outlasted Appalachian State in 2009 for a signature program win under coach Matt Viator. But it's likely the folks in Lake Charles, La., will be talking about Saturday's win against South Florida for much longer.
Viator's Cowboys didn't just beat South Florida for their second win against a team from a BCS automatic-qualifying conference (North Carolina, 1999). They lassoed the Bulls, using a 31-point second quarter to win 53-31, the largest margin of victory for an FCS team against a BCS AQ opponent.
"I thought we had a chance," Viator said. "Our kids were in shape, we were sound in the kicking game. That's usually what gets you against FBS teams. I didn't see something like this coming."
Each FCS team had its own source of motivation heading into the FBS showdowns. Eastern Washington had the close calls against the Pac-12. Northern Iowa had the near misses against Big Ten foes Wisconsin (2012) and Iowa (2009), not to mention the 67 Iowa natives on the roster. Viator's players showed up to the team breakfast Saturday inspired by North Dakota State's come-from-behind win at Kansas State the night before.
North Dakota State, the back-to-back defending FCS champion, is "the measuring stick for all of us," Viator said.
Eastern Illinois coach Dino Babers might have been too motivated for Saturday's opener at San Diego State. The San Diego native spent the 1994 season as a San Diego State assistant and couldn't stop yammering about the Aztecs all week.
"The biggest negative about this game was me because I knew so much about San Diego State," Babers said. "Nobody wanted to be around me. It was like I had stink juice on me. I was a grizzly bear."
EIU players also might have been sick of Babers talking about the team's 2001 game against San Diego State, when a quarterback named Tony Romo led the Panthers. That night, the Aztecs pummeled Eastern Illinois 40-7.
"I told them about it all week long," Babers said, "that Tony Romo's team went in there and scored only seven points. I love Tony, I know him now, so I know he won't get mad at me for saying it."
As if that wasn't enough, Babers had one final request in his pregame speech. His mother, Patsy Ann Plummer, doesn't fly and had never seen her son lead a team as a head coach.
She was scheduled to be at Qualcomm Stadium on Saturday night.
"I said, 'I knew you guys want to win, but it would be really cool if my mom could see a win,'" Babers said. "They said after the game, 'You get to be happy with your momma.' It's really cool."
The FCS coaches recognize the differences between their programs and those in the FBS, but they note that the gap is narrower in Week 1 than later in the season, when injuries take a toll. Opening weekend is by far the best opportunity to strike.
Northern Iowa coach Mark Farley had major questions about his team entering Iowa State's Jack Trice Stadium, not knowing what to expect in the secondary or at fullback or tight end. When Northern Iowa needed a fourth-down conversion late in the game, Farley watched tight end Braden Lehman, fullback Shawn Rush and others pave the way.
"Iowa State is a program on the rise," Farley said. "We beat them in front of a full house. But it wasn't about beating Iowa State. To finish one of these games and beat an FBS team, it takes more than 22 starters. It takes a lot of people pulling in the same direction. That's what really changed."
How many more opportunities Northern Iowa gets to take down FBS foes remains to be seen. The Big Ten Conference wants its teams to eliminate the scheduling of FCS foes, citing the scholarship discrepancies.
If other leagues follow suit, the guarantees FCS schools get for playing at FBS stadiums will disappear. According to ESPN's Darren Rovell, Eastern Washington ($450,000), McNeese State ($400,000) and North Dakota State ($350,000) all took home a little more than wins this weekend.
"We need these games," Farley said. "The reason we do this is to give every student-athlete a championship experience. FCS players should get up to play in these environments and these stadiums. As long as they're competitive games, it's a great thing for college football."
Week 1 was undoubtedly great for the FCS.
When informed about several other giant slayers, Baldwin replied, "Holy cow!" and "You're kidding!"
"You're happy for those teams," he said. "You know the limitations they have like you have, so when you see that, you know that's the type of game those guys remember for the rest of their lives."
BIG TEN SCOREBOARD
Final Eastern Illinois 20 Minnesota 42 Final Rutgers 41 Washington State 38
Final Penn State 26 UCF 24 Final Youngstown State 17 Illinois 28 Final Indiana State 10 Indiana 28 Final Northern Iowa 23 Iowa 31 Final Appalachian State 14 Michigan 52 Final 5 Ohio State 34 Navy 17 Final Western Michigan 34 Purdue 43 Final Florida Atlantic 7 22 Nebraska 55 Final California 31 Northwestern 24 Final James Madison 7 Maryland 52 Final 14 Wisconsin 24 13 LSU 28